Tried a few other people... it definitely does not overlap very well with how I've come to view them... It also drops the intermittent / art / tradition comments on almost everyone I fed into it (including non-hubski people).
My original test was with a blog post I wrote about dualism. Then I repeated with just hubski comments. The hubski content flattened out a lot of the extreme 99% this, 1% that, but things were mainly trended similarly. The written synopsis was similar in both cases. I'm surprised how often it says that the writer doesn't value art. I wonder what that's based on. Maybe we can get _refugee_ to drop some poetry on it, and see what it says.
Yeah, maybe it's just got a narrow definition of "art"? I've definitely discussed movies, music, and fiction on here... but maybe it's only accepts content found in a museum... that or the entire engine is overtrained. Looks from the docs that it was trained on <500 people, so I'm tempted to say it's not the most comprehensive of classifiers / judgers...I'm surprised how often it says that the writer doesn't value art. I wonder what that's based on. Maybe we can get _refugee_ to drop some poetry on it, and see what it says.
I threw 20p worth of poetry in (only about 4k words; i'll have to add 2k more from somewhere) and this is what I got (I have bolded the particularly hilarious bits): You are laid-back: you appreciate a relaxed pace in life. You are proud: you hold yourself in high regard, satisfied with who you are. And you are independent: you have a strong desire to have time to yourself. You are motivated to seek out experiences that provide a strong feeling of self-expression. You consider independence to guide a large part of what you do: you like to set your own goals to decide how to best achieve them. You are relatively unconcerned with tradition: you care more about making your own path than following what others have done. - Adventurousness33% - Artistic interests26% - Emotionality66% - Imagination59% - Intellect43% - Authority-challenging73% Conscientiousness25% - Achievement striving27% - Cautiousness28% - Dutifulness10% - Orderliness59% - Self-discipline20% - Self-efficacy25% Extraversion46% - Activity level3% - Assertiveness52% - Cheerfulness35% - Excitement-seeking25% - Outgoing12% - Gregariousness7% Agreeableness38% - Altruism10% - Cooperation18% - Modesty7% - Uncompromising16% - Sympathy50% - Trust9% Emotional range72% - Fiery68% - Prone to worry66% - Melancholy71% - Immoderation68% - Self-consciousness44% - Susceptible to stress73% Needs - Challenge11% - Closeness39% - Curiosity55% - Excitement35% - Harmony49% - Ideal55% - Liberty45% - Love17% - Practicality24% - Self-expression60% - Stability45% - Structure22% Values - Conservation16% - Openness to change86% - Hedonism63% - Self-enhancement35% - Self-transcendence79%You are a bit compulsive.
Openness54%
Here is almost 9k words of poems. Almost everything is the same. FWIW they are not mostly the same poems. You are laid-back: you appreciate a relaxed pace in life. You are proud: you hold yourself in high regard, satisfied with who you are. And you are independent: you have a strong desire to have time to yourself. You are motivated to seek out experiences that provide a strong feeling of self-expression. You are relatively unconcerned with tradition: you care more about making your own path than following what others have done. You value independence a bit more: you like to set your own goals to decide how to best achieve them. Adventurousness45% Artistic interests25% Emotionality53% Imagination68% Intellect52% Authority-challenging64% Conscientiousness32% Achievement striving25% Cautiousness36% Dutifulness14% Orderliness43% Self-discipline21% Self-efficacy19% Extraversion56% Activity level2% Assertiveness48% Cheerfulness37% Excitement-seeking20% Outgoing20% Gregariousness12% Agreeableness40% Altruism14% Cooperation26% Modesty7% Uncompromising17% Sympathy35% Trust14% Emotional range55% Fiery56% Prone to worry53% Melancholy63% Immoderation64% Self-consciousness32% Susceptible to stress56% Needs Challenge6% Closeness25% Curiosity39% Excitement23% Harmony27% Ideal47% Liberty34% Love9% Practicality10% Self-expression53% Stability30% Structure12% Values Conservation20% Openness to change74% Hedonism69% Self-enhancement33% Self-transcendence74% I find it interesting I don't score about a 74% in any category in this one. And in the above I think I don't go above 86.You are a bit inconsiderate.
Openness58%