a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by humanodon
humanodon  ·  4012 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Rich People Actually Don't Create The Jobs - Business Insider

Hey, I really appreciate your thoughtful and thorough response. I freely admit that my personal understanding of finance and economics is limited, but I am very interested in learning more. You seem to have a much better handle on it, so I'd like to ask: how do you think that jobs might better be created?

Also, I understand that credit allows people to buy much more expensive things, but how might the credit system be implemented in a way that does not lend itself to another financial crisis?





wasoxygen  ·  4012 days ago  ·  link  ·  

    Hey, I really appreciate your thoughtful and thorough response.
Great, thanks for saying so!

    I freely admit that my personal understanding of finance and economics is limited, but I am very interested in learning more.
I would say the same, on both counts.

    You seem to have a much better handle on it, I'd like to ask: how do you think that jobs might better be created?
Hm, I was hoping you would ask how it is that I can make myself appear to have a handle on economics, despite having no formal training.

As to creating jobs in a better way, I am afraid I don't know. Perhaps the way they are created now is not so bad. People look to increase their wealth by giving strangers stuff they want, so they start businesses to do that. If they have some success, they offer other strangers jobs to scale the process up and increase their wealth even more.

Many people, like Mr. Blodget, look to the government to make things better. I tend to think the government would do well to get out of the way. Another business magazine tells us that government is actively shutting down and stifling the very businesses that are creating jobs.

    Also, I understand that credit allows people to buy much more expensive things, but how might the credit system be implemented in a way that does not lend itself to another financial crisis?
It's all I can do to balance my checkbook, I would not dream of designing a credit system. I will observe that government is also up to its elbows in banking; it is one of the most regulated industries. This was true before the crisis, but after the crisis the answer was obvious: moar regulation.

If you pm me a mailing address, I would be happy to send you a book that provides a fascinating example of how credit -- in this case, microcredit -- can help pull people out of poverty.

humanodon  ·  4012 days ago  ·  link  ·  

    Hm, I was hoping you would ask how it is that I can make myself appear to have a handle on economics, despite having no formal training.

Heh, I would like to know! I think others might like to as well.

wasoxygen  ·  4012 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Appearing to know what you are talking about isn't too difficult; you can use the style of my comment above:

· bullet points

· links to external sources (especially Excel documents)

· an embedded graph

· quotes to suggest that you read the article

· an enumerated list

Actually feeling like you know what you are talking about is not so simple. I recommend following Feynman's advice:

    The first principle is that you must not fool yourself -- and you are the easiest person to fool.

Be honest and be humble. Don't say things you don't believe (without a good reason ), and don't believe things without good reason. You can't be wrong if you say you aren't sure. "Bend over backwards" to find out where you might be wrong.

The rest is just doing your homework. Research takes time, but that is how you find evidence. And it's so easy these days, at least if you are writing for Hubski and not a peer-reviewed journal. Half of my sources are on Wikipedia.

The result is that you feel increasingly ignorant in an increasingly complex world. But when you do draw conclusions, even though they are not certain, they are grounded in something more substantial than hearsay and chatter.

humanodon  ·  4011 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Oh, so it's just like being a teacher then, but in text format :)

I haven't read much Feynman, so I appreciate the link!