a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by kleinbl00
kleinbl00  ·  4813 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: A Term We are Going to Hear Ad Nauseum Until Nov 6 2012 - Class Warfare
Ahhh, but the battlefield is semantics. The media is the message, as Marshall McLuhan said.

Consider - "actual" warfare in this day and age means "a bunch of kids I don't know go to a country I can't locate on a map and kill people I don't know the first thing about and occasionally show up on the news until Nancy Grace finds a white girl in trouble" to most people.

Actual warfare, meanwhile, has morphed to "UAV pilots in Nevada launch missile strikes in Pakistan against targets that are either Taliban or a Pashtun wedding party, depending on our intel."

Does "warfare" mean "death?" Well, how many people die from shoddy healthcare? Does that not count? If a rich person lobbies for a means test on social security that ends up killing 30 people because they ate melamine-enhanced Chinese catfood to stay alive, is he more or less culpable than the Air Force pilot who maneuvers a Predator into striking distance so a CIA operative can press the trigger?

I wrote this about two years ago when someone asked whether there was a fiscally-conservative but socially-liberal political party:

http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/8d9zi/anyone_else...

The TL;DR is that the only way the Republican Party can operate for its wealthy benefactors is by convincing the proletariat to vote against its best interests, and that's all about semantics.

As to your aside, "climate skepticism" is the right's version of "vaccine skepticism." It is a deeply-held, irrational belief that is more emotionally investing than intellectually investing and as such, clever people irrationally cling to questionable data points in order to avoid the cognitive discomfort necessary to purge an entire regime of thought. After all, if Al Gore was right about Global Warming, he might be right about other things... and it's so much easier if Al Gore is 100% WRONG.

Politics does not occupy the same place in our brains as "right vs. wrong." It occupies the same place as "Raiders vs. Packers."





mayonesa  ·  4808 days ago  ·  link  ·  
I'm not sure the proletariat is voting against its own best interests.

As individuals, perhaps.

As a nation? No -- and we all benefit from that.

thenewgreen  ·  4813 days ago  ·  link  ·  
"In other words, the less cash in your pocket, the easier platitudes like "Adam and Eve, not Adam and Steve" nestle into the folds of your cerebrum. Reality is actually quite nuanced - more nuanced than most working-class scutworkers have time to deal with. So they're big on anthems. And an easy one is "down with the rich!" Platitudes like "Raising taxes is class warfare". great post.
thenewgreen  ·  4813 days ago  ·  link  ·  
I thoroughly enjoyed your comment/link. This statement, ".... until Nancy Grace finds a white girl in trouble" to most people". Would be hilarious if it wasn't so true. Absolutism (it's either this or this) combined with the sport of politics is where we find ourselves.