Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking. Login or Take a Tour!
I don’t understand your objection, is it a Chinese room argument? The author doesn’t claim that search engines understand what cities or time are, just that the algorithms successfully give the information requested, as a reliable human assistant would. The carbon vs. silicon debate might consider how useful a carbon-based mechanism would be if it had no access to silicon-based tools and data. For now the two substrates are interdependent.