a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by cgod
cgod  ·  1519 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Social Cooling

Advertising is motive force that is ruining everything.

It's why we think buying more things might finally make us happy. Consuming our way to a destroyed earth and an insatiable apatite that can never be sated. The essential trick is to make you feel like you aren't good enough and things can make you happier, thinner, prettier, smarter ect.

It's why my healthy nine year old thinks she is fat.

It's why our news panders to the extremes, pushing us further and further from each other. Shock and outrage sells more tooth paste and cars.





wasoxygen  ·  1519 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I don't think that buying more things will improve my baseline happiness, but I do get pleasure from my consumer behavior. Today's consumerist society comes with costs, but stress and insecurity aren't new, and maybe not a bad tradeoff for the agricultural lifestyle we left behind. Communes are out there for people who get bored with their four hours of daily television.

I'm just trying to find out what would make mk happy. He doesn't want Facebook to sell user data, but when the documentary says they don't sell data, he expresses concern about gathering data.

He says it's okay if someone searching for "stem cell storage" sees an ad for Forever Labs, but if they search for "Wankel engine" and land on a car video, Mazda should "absolutely" be blocked from showing an ad with that video (though his next sentence seems to say the reverse).

My point is not that privacy is worthless, but that Mazda's desire to sell cars will not be reduced by making it harder for them to find customers. They will adjust to controls on targeted advertising, perhaps with larger and less discriminating campaigns. That means more demand for ads, and more revenue and influence for Facebook.

mk  ·  1517 days ago  ·  link  ·  
mk  ·  1518 days ago  ·  link  ·  

    He doesn't want Facebook to sell user data, but when the documentary says they don't sell data, he expresses concern about gathering data.

Facebook gathers the data not just on their platform, but by tracking you elsewhere. Also, Facebook sells the use of the data for marketing.

    He says it's okay if someone searching for "stem cell storage" sees an ad for Forever Labs, but if they search for "Wankel engine" and land on a car video, Mazda should "absolutely" be blocked from showing an ad with that video (though his next sentence seems to say the reverse).

I am fine with presenting ads next to search terms. I am not ok with marketing based upon a profile that is built for me. I am less ok with it if it is shared between companies, and even less so if it is created by tracking my behavior.

It is ok if Mazda has to work harder to sell cars or if Forever Labs has to work harder to sell stem cell banking. That's how advertising worked for more than a century. It won't mean more revenue for Facebook, as it will mean a lower ROI on their ad service.