a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by ooli
ooli  ·  2049 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Sci-Fi club no. 40: A Colder War Discussion

I love Sci-fi. Must be the only genre I like. Except.. beside Frank Herbert, I never found some good sci-fi.

Asimov is good, but with stupid character sometime.

And most of the other, from Dan Simmons to C. Clark , F. Leiber (the one who wrote the same story twice, in 2 trilogy) , Jack Vance, Van vogt (at least, this one is funny for his personal heel face turn ), they all lack constructed clever story.. and as I said, I dont like sci-fi close in the future, like all the cyberpunk sub-genre.

Ok Zelazny, get a pass. He is funny with real original setting.

Herbert> Zelazny> Asimov > Every one else > K.Dick

So thanks for the recommendation. I'll read the summary ....

Ok I just read it on wiki

Now, I remember!!

I read that Book. I should have remember It has the same title in french.

I loved the premise. and was disappointed by the solution. On the grip hand, at the time I read it (if I remember well, I took it in my small local library under the Sacré Coeur.. or my modern library in Strasbourg... or I should check in my bookcase if I bought it)... anyway , at that time, I had no idea of the Fermi paradox.

But imho, it is still a lackluster resolution, so I never read anything else from the guy. That's the problem: when I love the basic mystery, the author better deliver on the resolution, or I get real pissed.

Maybe the 2 others tome are better. Guess I'll never know





Devac  ·  2047 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Out of curiosity, have you read The Cyberiad by Lem? It's definitely a good example of humorous/funny sci-fi – even accounting for my Polish bias – and I have a hunch you'd also like it.

kleinbl00  ·  2049 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Which is interesting because I had a really hard time with Frank Herbert.

Spin is a better book than the next two but Spin doesn't really resolve the Fermi Paradox. The other two books do.

    That's the problem: when I love the basic mystery, the author better deliver on the resolution, or I get real pissed.

Right there with ya. That's probably why I hated Three Body Problem so much.