Thanks, I remember that post, but missed most of the discussion. I am not convinced that so-called bullshit jobs are so bad; I have argued that workplace conditions have gotten a good bit better than they were in the days when actual bull shit was a feature of many laborers' workplace. And I think it requires some energetic handwaving to say that an office job is useless when, by definition, it involves labor that someone is willing to pay for. I don't think I am unusual in that I began my career with few valuable skills and started by doing unpleasant and low-paid work that very gradually led to a comparatively comfortable cubicle. It will take some fine tuning to work out how you give a young person more money than they can earn without compromising their motivation to start getting experience. In short, the "average" (median, or whatever) worker in a given place has a far better deal than at any time in the past, and this despite centuries of fear of automation bringing ruin to workers.