a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by GoatFood
GoatFood  ·  4675 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Question for Hubski: Why do people give? Why do you?
I give because of white guilt. I have far too much for doing very little. I feel guilty that I have so many resources and assets, and that I am able to enjoy a positive, stable standing in society simply because I am a straight white male born into a middle class family. All that makes me feel really bad. So I give in order to alleviate some of that guilt, that I might improve the standing of other people in society. I want to reduce their hardships and hopefully give them the opportunity to work towards a life more like mine. Giving away what I have makes me feel less bad that others have so little.




thenewgreen  ·  4675 days ago  ·  link  ·  
Thanks GoatFood, I appreciate your candor. I think guilt plays a very real part in charitable giving. It's hard not to see those that are suffering and not feel guilty as you drive around in a nice car or eat a nice meal. Hell, it's hard to not feel guilty that you don't have to worry about where your next meal will come from or if it will come at all.

When you give, would you be more likely to give to help a specific person or to an organization? Will that difference influence how much you give?

GoatFood  ·  4675 days ago  ·  link  ·  
It depends on the context. I live in an area where there is not much visible poverty, so when I do see someone panhandling I usually give a small amount to them. If I am looking to actually donate money, however, I am more likely to donate to organizations. I base my decision to donate on how I know my money will be used. I would not be very likely to donate to the WWF, even though I support their cause, because I don't have a clear idea of how my money will be spent. Conversely, I donated money to IDE for the purpose of distributing water pumps to subsistence farmers in developing nations. http://www.ideorg.org/OurTechnologies/TreadlePump.aspx I chose their organization because they do innovative work. I think that aid should work from the ground up, and enable the poor to lift themselves out of poverty. Those pumps enable farmers to grow crops more effectively, and thus turn a greater income. I think building a viable economy is the best way to solve complex issues in developing nations (or even developed ones, really). Thus, I am more likely to donate to organizations that provide aid from the ground up, rather than just throwing money at an issue.
thenewgreen  ·  4675 days ago  ·  link  ·  
I base my decision to donate on how I know my money will be used. -This is a big part of how I decide to allocate my $. Unfortunately, I have seen first hand how inefficient some of my favorite non-profits are. Some of them move extremely slowly and they have no sense of urgency. -They're often lazy.