a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by AdMan707
AdMan707  ·  3791 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: An Elegy for the Age of Space

This is overly America-centric. Like reading an ancient Greek historian equate the dissolution of the triumvirate with an impending disuse of the Corinthian collum. How could he know that Rome would use it ad absurdum? Well, it's both decorative and retains the efficient load bearing function of the Ionic and Doric collum. Why wouldn't it last? Similarly, there are more solid elements like nickel in the asteroid belt than there are on 100 earths (based on what we've observed so far). The first company or country to exploit the resources in the asteroid belt will be richer than anyone or any country in history. It is literally a floating gold mine out there. And, like the Greeks, the fall of their empire triggered the rise of another, as niches get filled by rule of necessity. Similarly, there are plenty of obvious and probably plenty of obscure nations or collectives ready to fill the niche left behind when the US finally putters out as a world leader, however long that takes. I don't have to try hard to imagine India or China filling that niche rather quickly. They certainly have the muscle and the expendable resources (and people). So while I agree that the current state of human space exploration is dismal, I think the author is confusing a corner with a dead end. Somebody is going to get to those resources or that money (or bring it to them by "catching" an asteroid), it just probably won't be Russia or the US who pulls it off.

Tl;dr - there is way too much unclaimed wealth floating in space to believe that no one will find a way to get to it.





am_Unition  ·  3791 days ago  ·  link  ·  

You're absolutely right.

I just find it unfortunate that the spirit of manned spaceflight will shift from an exploratory, scientific nature to a profit-based, corporation-driven endeavor.

AdMan707  ·  3791 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Once the technology is routine, someone else might use it to explore. But if you think about it, "exploration" was just window dressing on the Apollo missions. Those were about the cold war in terms of funding and public support. Even "Apollo 13" the film admitted this. Once we had beaten the USSR, people didn't want their tax dollars spent to keep going back. Columbus found the Caribbean while trying to forge a shorter trade route to India on behalf of the Spanish crown. It's all about money and power. It's ALWAYS been about money and power.

am_Unition  ·  3791 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I wasn't alive yet during the cold war, and am admittedly romanticizing our space race... it was indeed an arms race, first and foremost.

Spot on again, AdMan.