a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by JackTheBandit
JackTheBandit  ·  3851 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Is it time we took the focus off the DJ?

Within the context of America, I think this is a result of there being no promotion of rhythm as a core part of cultural expression. (Generalization incoming) The target audience for this "EDM" wave are kids that didn't grow up in households where dancing was a focus in gatherings. I don't even think it's necessarily that the focus is put on the DJ. Rather, it's that these people dont know how to do anything but watch the DJ. The discussion has happened elsewhere on Hubski where we talk about the millenials (and after) being children that were basically insulated and monitored all the time with no room to express themselves freely. This would probably translate to them not being able to dance nor feeling comfortable with trying to dance.

I've mentioned it before, but I'm of Caribbean heritage. Learning how to dance to Reggae, Soca, and Calypso are huge parts of the cultural experience as a child. Especially in NYC. You could pick any random Caribbean American youth in this city and they'd have stories about dancing at family and neighborhood barbecues. It's something you also see in Hispanic, African, and African American communities as well. Dancing as a form of expression are integral to cultural experience.

Techno and House have a dancing culture around them too, but when they were brought to the surface that aspect was dropped because it wouldn't translate to this new audience. However, if you go back underground, so to speak, you'll find people putting 4 on the floor because that's what you do and the energy you feel during that time is an amazing experience. There's a well respected and new-ish club in Brooklyn called Output that caters to this audience. They have a "no photos" policy and you will see security enforcing it fairly regularly. It's understood that you come to Output to hear good music, dance and interact with the crowd around you. Not pay for VIP, take selfies for the gram, and "pray to the DJ."

That said I can't wait to make the pilgrimage to Detroit next week for Movement.





am_Unition  ·  3851 days ago  ·  link  ·  

    I don't even think it's necessarily that the focus is put on the DJ. Rather, it's that these people dont know how to do anything but watch the DJ.

Spot on.

I've asked friends who were clearly enjoying themselves why they don't bust a move, and they say, "Oh, I can't dance." That's always tickled me. "Can't dance" should be a label reserved for quadriplegics.

It's possible to be "bad" at dancing, but that's a pretty subjective term. Someone doing the worm might be more fun to watch than someone else just waving their arms back and forth, but who really cares? It doesn't matter how old you are, how white you are,, or what music gets you going, you can dance.

You're absolutely right though, it's a question of cultures and comfort zones.

rezzeJ  ·  3851 days ago  ·  link  ·  

One of the great things about going to a club with a bunch of like minded people is that it doesn't matter how you dance. You just move your body in the way you feel the beat compels you to. Even if you've never danced before, a basic dance can be just an extension of bopping your head. All you need to do is twist your shoulders from side to side at the same time and bounce on your legs a bit. Voila, you can now dance at a club.

Of course, it'll be years before you're throwing moves like this.

JackTheBandit  ·  3851 days ago  ·  link  ·  

OMG that video is A1 lol. But yes, your point is valid.