a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by thundara
thundara  ·  3871 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Why Google’s Modular Smartphone Might Actually Succeed | Google Project Ara

    Most people are going to want to build a phone that does what they want and use it. If it doesn't do what they want they'll want to swap maybe one or two things, not everything. The majority of the design is going to be static - yes, you'll want to be able to take it apart but you aren't going to be doing it at parties.

It reminds me a bit of desktop computers: Tired of your slow CPU? Open it up and swap it out. Need more RAM? Open it up and swap it out. It turns "toss out the computer" into "toss out a few chips."

I got my laptop in 2010. It's still kicking okay, but if I wanted to stop the disk thrashing when I open 20 browser tabs, it'd just be a matter of swapping out the RAM. Same goes for faster boots with a SSD. Same goes for compiling and a CPU. This can be repeated until hardware makers decide they need a new type of socket to improve performance.

Outside of tech enthusiasts and niche markets, I see the benefits as less of the present: "lemme hotswap my camera at a party" and more of the future: "I want 802.11ac, lemme toss the radio instead of tossing the phone." "I cracked my screen, lemme replace that."

A little cheaper and a little more environmentally friendly than the current smartphone situation.





kleinbl00  ·  3871 days ago  ·  link  ·  

It makes sense, really. We've reached a point where the average consumer doesn't need all the goddamn horsepower you can buy anymore, either in a phone, or a desktop, or a laptop, or a tablet. If people had discipline about photos and videos they'd never need to upgrade again, other than the pernicious habit of making ever-more-resource-intensive operating systems.

But something like this would just about solve the problem. Build two, maybe three buses - a girl-sized phone, a nerd-sized phone, and a texting flipper. Give it three slots (two front, one back) for cameras. Give it a wireless slot. Give it a charge/IO slot. Give it a battery slot. Give it a speaker slot (or two, 'cuz people think you get stereo an inch apart FFS). Build it all around a memory slot, a CPU slot, a GPU slot and three different sizes of screen slots and you're off to the races.

It'll take a company like Google or Amazon to do that, though, because in order to pursue this model you have to be hell-bent on annihilating your competition through forbearance of profit.

thundara  ·  3871 days ago  ·  link  ·  

    It'll take a company like Google or Amazon to do that, though, because in order to pursue this model you have to be hell-bent on annihilating your competition through forbearance of profit.

Yeah, that's the trouble. On one hand, the consumer doesn't need to replace their entire phone as often. On the other, the consumer doesn't need to replace their entire phone as often.

Plus all the headaches of compatible hardware, 3rd party knock-offs, and dysfunctional, proprietary drivers.

    We've reached a point where the average consumer doesn't need all the goddamn horsepower you can buy anymore, either in a phone, or a desktop, or a laptop, or a tablet

I don't know if that's necessarily true of phones / tablets / laptops, but it definitely happened in the desktop market. I could build a fancy gaming computer now for less than my laptop costed in 2010.

kleinbl00  ·  3871 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Best phone I ever had was an iPhone 3G running iOS 3. That was pretty much the pinnacle of usability. Compared to my wife's hot-shit 5S, it didn't have:

- a magic-ass fingerprint sensor not quite as good as the one I disabled on my Thinkpad in 2006

- a selfie camera

- Facetime

- a compass

It did, however, have a maps app that would get you where you were going most of the time. Sure, no turn-by-turn but that's because Steve Jobs was often an ass. See also: Copy and Paste, which weren't available until this operating system.

I've used the compass on my phone twice now. You can probably guess how much the selfie camera and Facetime get used. So really, in the six intervening years between then and now, the major improvement in my life is turn-by-turn, which I had on my HTC Harrier in 2004.

I think we overestimate how badly we need our phones to be hot shit because the software bloats and bloats and bloats and bloats to the point where you need a 2GHz processor just to answer a goddamn phone call. iOS 5 was 750MB. Fuckin' iOS 7 is 3GB. Tomb Raider for the PS3 is 4. I really think we could get by with less.