a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by lil
lil  ·  3940 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: "in thy beauty is the dilemma of flutes" (e. e. cummings - "My Love" )

The words are pretty -- but what does he think of her?

    thy head is a quick forest/filled with sleeping birds

    thy head is a casket/of the cool jewel of thy mind

He's saying, I think, that she's brain dead.

I think if I was his love I'd be insulted...





humanodon  ·  3940 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Oh, so many things can be charming or insulting, depending on how one says them (or reads them).

I think it's funny that the metaphors for legs have to do with trees and horses and that the lips are described as satraps. These are all powerful things that tend toward the masculine. Or at least they can be construed that way.

b_b  ·  3940 days ago  ·  link  ·  

    He's saying, I think, that she's brain dead.

For whatever reason this website is blocked at work, so I can't read the context, but I don't read it that way. I think he is pointing out that she perhaps doesn't use the gifts that she has. A forest filled with sleeping birds sounds more dormant than dead. Birds are mysterious and beautiful creatures that display complex behavior individually and collectively, and also make beautiful music. When they sleep, they still possess these qualities, but they aren't using them at the moment.

The casket line I can't really make heads or tails of, however, so maybe you're correct.

_refugee_  ·  3940 days ago  ·  link  ·  

To me, the "cool jewel" of her mind reads as if her mind is detached. Perhaps calculating, perhaps very intellectual. However, it is still locked away - hidden, perhaps. Jewels catch in and reflect light. They are also hard (typically) and, although now I'm taking the esoteric interpretation up a notch, not forgiving.

My favorite is the line about "thy legs are the trees of dreaming." Where does fruit grow? At the top of trees! And you eat fruit. Come on. I think that couplet is so much more sexual - and sexy! - than the lines about her thighs!

lil  ·  3940 days ago  ·  link  ·  

My Love E. E. Cummings

  my love
  thy hair is one kingdom
    the king whereof is darkness
  thy forehead is a flight of flowers

  thy head is a quick forest
    filled with sleeping birds
  thy breasts are swarms of white bees
    upon the bough of thy body
  thy body to me is April
  in whose armpits is the approach of spring

  thy thighs are white horses yoked to a chariot
    of kings
  they are the striking of a good minstrel
  between them is always a pleasant song

  my love
  thy head is a casket
    of the cool jewel of thy mind
  the hair of thy head is one warrior
    innocent of defeat
  thy hair upon thy shoulders is an army
    with victory and with trumpets

  thy legs are the trees of dreaming
  whose fruit is the very eatage of forgetfulness

  thy lips are satraps in scarlet
    in whose kiss is the combinings of kings
  thy wrists
  are holy
    which are the keepers of the keys of thy blood
  thy feet upon thy ankles are flowers in vases
    of silver

  in thy beauty is the dilemma of flutes

    thy eyes are the betrayal
    of bells comprehended through incense