I too am at the mercy of what they call an ABC store here in North Carolina. It sucks, and the selection is horrible. So I can understand your past frustrations. However, look what I found: The official Rye of Hubski. b_b, it's going to be a nice thanksgiving!
Normally the selection here is pretty slim, I was as surprised as anyone. Let me know how your selections fair. Currently having a Bulleit Manhattan I made per my mother-in-laws request. I don't think she knew what she was asking for.... My father-in-law is in for a fun night. :)
Enjoy! I hope I can find some, too, but I'm sure I'll manage to drink too much whiskey even if it's not redemption. BTW, you have any recommendations on a good brand of vermouth and/or bitters? I know you're a cocktail guy. Thinking about mixing Manhattans (as I really enjoyed drinking them the other day, and what better way to use rye?!), but I don't have any experience whatsoever in the cocktail game.