For me, I love Doolittle by Pixies. In case the embedded link isn't working, Side A of the vinyl transfer can be found here and Side B of the vinyl transfer here. I can't imagine listening to the songs out of order, it just feels . . . wrong. Honestly, when CD players came out with the shuffle option, I thought it was kind of lame. Someone took the time (in most cases) to arrange the tracks into a cohesive piece, making an effort to have the album unfold for the listener just so. Even now I listen to albums this way unless I'm hosting people.
Also, I mentioned a documentary on the Pixies and their impact on acts from the UK called Gouge so I thought I'd post a link.