a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment
JTHipster  ·  4380 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Hitler’s Strange Afterlife in India - The Daily Beast

True, but also nobody cares about his book.

This seems to be an article written for an American or western audience. A good writer would thus use a book or topic that Americans/Westerners would understand. We all understand Mein Kampf. We know who wrote it and that its not really hugely popular in the West.

If he had picked a book about Ghandi, everyone in the West reading the article would understand the comparison, because we know Ghandi is famous pretty much everywhere. If Mein Kampf sold like...half as much as a pretty famous book either about or by Ghandi, we would all be like "oh hey, that IS a lot!"

Instead he compared it to his book. I can't even find how many people in the U.S. bought his book. Apparently it was sort of terrible according to every review that wasn't on Amazon, so I dunno. I could see how it'd be a pretty terrible book judging by how the article was written.

This was actually a super interesting topic that was made incredibly boring by a pretty mediocre writer.