a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment
kleinbl00  ·  887 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Pubski: June 22, 2022

Spindle stories

The spindle is the spinny thing you attach tools to. "runout" is how much it wiggles in its orbit while it does so. This particular spindle company is known for unreal precision and runouts to a tenth of a micron.

Mine requires four kinds of air. I had no information on it. Fortunately the company that made mine had recently refurbished one (sequentially, the serial number after mine) for Patek Philippe, so they had specs. Those specs were transliterated poorly, so a friend who makes parts for Arnold & Son was able to help me.

I inquired as to what it would cost to get said spindle rebuilt, because it probably needed it (the prior owner had savaged the encoder cables off below the nut, and who knows what else). I was informed that their overhaul was "around $18-20k" and they gave me the name of a company in NC who could do it faster for less.

I have 85 pictures of the horrorshow that is my spindle. They gave me a quote of $7k, and then didn't bat an eye when I asked if they could increase their tolerances by an order of magnitude to match factory spec.

Mathematically, which means assuming no ball screw backlash which is nonsense, the precision in X, Y and Z will be half a micron. It will be more than that because there is ball screw backlash. However, with the addition of closed-loop modules for the servo packs ($300 ea) and absolute encoders ($X - under research), the absolute precision of the X, Y and Z can be reduced to 0.01 microns. That's 10 nanometers, or the difference between orangey-yellow and yellowy-orange.

Theory and practice are two totally different things, but in theory it's gonna be sumpin'.