a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment
Kaius  ·  3757 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Should your robot driver kill you to save a child's life?

"Should I laugh like an evil genius or a bond villain after I throw a very life like child mannequin in front of my sworn enemies RoboCar?" was the thought that entered my mind when reading this.

The situation in the article is a really contrived example to represent a closed context with one option (car, tunnel, child, someone will die but who) and seeks to evoke a level of "Justice must be upheld" feeling in the readers response. Its a shitty scenario and in today's world kids who fall in the middle of the road get killed and unless the driver was speeding or impaired in some fashion the whole incident is chalked up to being an unfortunate event with little real blame going anywhere. Why would we change this now simple because we have the option to do so and any split second decision based on the "age" of the victims as representing their value is a very risky one indeed.

But beyond the hypothetical lets talk market forces, how eager would you be to drive a car that may kill you to save a stranger? I think id be upgrading the firmware on that baby pretty quickly. Yea i'll take the "Save the owner and his family in all scenarios" option along with the 21" alloys.