a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment
theadvancedapes  ·  4026 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Can We Live Forever?

    There are all these online groups of educated people who identify as atheist but they become so headstrong in their atheism that it has almost turned into a religion itself.

The "New Atheists" have been compared to a religious movement quite frequently. I think some of the parallels are there, but in my mind the main criteria for a religion is belief in the supernatural so IMO it doesn't really qualify. I think the reason some see them as a religious group is because they are just as passionate about religion not existing as religious people are about their religious belief.

    There are now conferences and meetups in which these groups of people are coming together in real life to share their views.

I like this. I think its important for the areligious to meet and share their views and organize. Especially for people that just realized religion is wrong and are only surrounded with family and friends that believe.

    In this case it is broadening the traditional definition of religion (a belief in a higher power or superhuman figure) but the group of people coming together to talk, listen, discuss and share their beliefs remains. Even if that belief is that they don't believe.

Ya, the function and structure share common parallels. System parallels. You can actually say the same about any major religion and the scientific enterprise. Just as major religions have their symbolic figure heads (e.g., Jesus, Mohammed, Joseph Smith, L. Ron Hubbard), we have our own symbolic figures heads (e.g., Isaac Newton, Charles Darwin, Albert Einstein, etc.). Just as major religions have places of worship, centers of power, and important socio-geographical landmarks (e.g., Vatican, Wailing Wall, Mecca, etc.) we have our own versions of those things (e.g., Sagan Walk, Down House, Galapagos Islands, Oxford, etc.). Even the pervasiveness of the belief structures in daily life shares commonalities. People who believe in a major religion believe that their god will save them from disease, death, and make sure they are well-fed and safe... whereas people in secular society believe that science can fill those functions.

    There are certainly obvious differences and I have yet to see a bunch of singularity preachers on the street corners

You may not see singularity preachers on street corners... but that's because we are too tech savvy for that. We have blogs.

    Anyways. Great job on the video. I can't wait to see more!

Thanks :-)