a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment
_refugee_  ·  4058 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: How Not to Argue about Human Rights

Marcotte is quoted as saying

    We respect these rights because we know that people’s lives are made worse if they don’t have them.

This is such a broad, general, and non-quantifiable statement. A right is something that "people's lives are made worse if they don't have them"? I don' t have a million dollars and when compared to someone who does, I'm sure my life is worse. I don't own a house. I have student debt which, thank god, I can pay, but I don't have the right to declare bankruptcy on.

Can I get a house and discharge my student debt please? My life is much worse without these things.

I think she means "significantly worse off" but it's still completely unquantifiable and subjective. And there are a lot of people who ride the bus 2-4 hours a day whose lives would be made a lot better if they had either better transportation or their own transportation. I don't see the gov't getting ready to assert that a car is basic human right though.