a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment
mk  ·  4961 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: What do you say to an alien?
>The most dominant graphic is an engraving of man and woman, his hand upraised in a greeting gesture. This is hardly a universal gesture especially if the aliens who find it have no limbs. Or it could be taken as downright obscene in some corners of the Galaxy.

I think that makes little sense. How could aliens think that we have the same gestures? Or that we had knowledge of theirs? It is our gesture, that's the point. We are just saying "This is what we do. It's our greeting gesture."

>The scientists say that another problem is in our assumption that aliens can properly perceive pictures or sounds with their own unique sensory organs.

I'm sure they'll figure it out. That's the point. If we got a message from an intelligent extra-solar species, we'd put tremendous energy and time into examining it. We'd probably find more in it than that is there.

As for what I'd put: I think the Voyager and Pioneer missions did well. They started with basic shared information, the excitation of electrons in hydrogen, and build up from there. I think the pulsar position map is a good idea too.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voyager_Golden_Record http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pioneer_plaque

I don't think the intent of the message is important. We are just giving them a primer, so the more information they have, the more context they have to build a picture from. Let's given them enough to have fun. I'd send Wikipedia if I could. -In multiple languages. They would decode it in no time, with no help from us. We could do the same, and chances are, they are far more advanced.

For a EM signal that we sent out, I'd send a repeating signal, that was a sequence of primes. Maybe have the primes alternate at two nearby frequencies, creating a binary signal that coded the message.